Hayes Theater, New York The Tony winner is as captivating as ever as a troubled matriarch but Paula Vogel's emotionally underpowered play often struggles to meet her level At a performance of Pulitzer prize winner Paula Vogel's late stage Tonys contender Mother Play, opening a day before eligibility ends, one can pick from three bright and syrupy themed cocktails before purchasing a tie-in cap graced with the word MO…